Tabletop Companion

Paper Cutter Guide

You will need to cut your proxy cards to size and round the corners. Here are the best paper cutters for the job.

We research our recommendations and are reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Learn more

Paper Cutter Comparison

RECOMMENDED
Kadomaru Pro / Pro Neo

Kadomaru Pro / Pro Neo

Cutting Precision
Build Quality
Value for Money
Ease of Use
Advantages
  • 3mm radius is perfect for MTG cards
  • Multiple corner radius options (3mm, 5mm, 8mm)
  • Pro Neo requires less effort and can cut larger thicknesses of paper
Disadvantages
  • Non-Neo can be hard to cut through thicker paper
R3 3mm Radius Heavy Duty Corner Cutter

R3 3mm Radius Heavy Duty Corner Cutter

Cutting Precision
Build Quality
Value for Money
Ease of Use
Advantages
  • Can handle very heavy materials
  • Durable metal construction
Disadvantages
  • Limited to 3mm radius only (no adjustable options)
RECOMMENDED
Dahle 507 Personal Rotary Trimmer

Dahle 507 Personal Rotary Trimmer

Cutting Thickness
Build Quality
Value for Money
Ease of Use
Advantages
  • Can cut through thick materials
  • Self-sharpening blade
Disadvantages
  • Higher price point than basic trimmers
  • Precise but difficult to find the correct line to cut
RECOMMENDED
Fiskars Precision Paper Trimmer

Fiskars Precision Paper Trimmer

Cutting Thickness
Build Quality
Value for Money
Ease of Use
Advantages
  • Very easy to be precise
Disadvantages
  • Cutting blade needs to be replaced
  • Struggles with thicker materials
Swingline Paper Cutter, Guillotine Trimmer

Swingline Paper Cutter, Guillotine Trimmer

Cutting Thickness
Build Quality
Value for Money
Ease of Use
Advantages
  • Can handle thicker materials and multiple sheets
  • Sharp steel blade for clean, precise cuts
Disadvantages
  • Blade needs regular maintenance and sharpening
Tonic Studios Paper Cutter Tool - Guillotine

Tonic Studios Paper Cutter Tool - Guillotine

Cutting Thickness
Build Quality
Value for Money
Ease of Use
Advantages
  • Can handle cardstock and multiple paper sheets
  • Sharp blade for clean, precise cuts
Disadvantages
  • Blade needs regular maintenance and sharpening
RECOMMENDED
Silhouette Portrait 4

Silhouette Portrait 4

Cutting Thickness
Build Quality
Value for Money
Ease of Use
Advantages
  • Can cut cards out with rounded corners
  • Good value for money
Disadvantages
  • May be overwhelming for beginners
Cricut Explore 4

Cricut Explore 4

Cutting Thickness
Build Quality
Value for Money
Ease of Use
Advantages
  • Can cut cards out with rounded corners
Disadvantages
  • Pricey
  • Learning curve for software and machine operation
Silhouette Cameo 5

Silhouette Cameo 5

Cutting Thickness
Build Quality
Value for Money
Ease of Use
Advantages
  • Can cut cards out with rounded corners
Disadvantages
  • Premium price point
  • May be overwhelming for beginners

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the difference between a paper trimmer and a guillotine cutter?
Paper trimmers use a sliding blade mechanism that moves along a track, while guillotine cutters use a hinged blade that chops down like a traditional paper cutter. Trimmers are generally safer and easier to use, while guillotine cutters can handle thicker materials and multiple sheets.
What cutting length do I need for proxy cards?
For proxy cards, a 10-12 inch cutting length is ideal. This allows you to cut multiple cards at once from a standard 8.5x11 inch sheet. If you're only cutting one card at a time, a smaller trimmer will work, but larger trimmers are more efficient for batch cutting.
Can I use scissors instead of a paper cutter?
While scissors can work for cutting proxy cards, they won't provide the same precision and consistency as a paper cutter. Scissors can lead to uneven edges and inconsistent card sizes. A paper cutter ensures uniform, professional-looking results.
How do I maintain my paper cutter blade?
Keep the blade clean by wiping it with a soft cloth after use. Avoid cutting materials that could dull the blade like cardboard or laminated paper. Most paper cutters have replaceable blades - replace when cuts become ragged or require multiple passes.
What safety precautions should I take when using a paper cutter?
Always use the safety guard if provided, keep fingers away from the cutting area, and ensure the cutter is on a stable surface. For guillotine cutters, use the safety lock when not in use. Never leave children unsupervised with paper cutters.
How do I get perfectly straight cuts?
Use the grid markings on the cutter to align your paper precisely. Make sure the paper is flat and not curled. Apply even pressure when cutting, and don't rush the cutting motion. For best results, practice on scrap paper first.