Tabletop Companion

Proxy Printer Guide

Explore the best printers for creating vibrant, high-quality card proxies for tabletop games. Compare features, costs, and print quality to find your perfect match.

We research our recommendations and are reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Learn more

Printer Comparison

Brother MFC-J4335DW
Cheapest Startup

Brother MFC-J4335DW

Image Quality
Text Quality
Cost Per Print
Cardstock Handling
Advantages
  • Lower running cost than standard cartridge printers
  • Large ink cartridges available
Disadvantages
  • 4-color ink system
  • Running costs are higher than true refillable tank systems
RECOMMENDED
Epson EcoTank ET-2980
True Budget Queen

Epson EcoTank ET-2980

Image Quality
Text Quality
Cost Per Print
Cardstock Handling
Advantages
  • Extremely low cost per print
  • Refillable ink tanks
  • Good photo quality
Disadvantages
  • 4-color ink system
  • Higher upfront cost compared to cartridge models
RECOMMENDED
Canon PIXMA G620 MegaTank
Picture Perfect Photo

Canon PIXMA G620 MegaTank

Image Quality
Text Quality
Cost Per Print
Cardstock Handling
Advantages
  • Refillable ink tanks
  • Produces lab-quality photos with accurate colors
Disadvantages
  • Can struggle with thicker cardstock
  • Small white text can be hard to read
RECOMMENDED
Epson EcoTank Photo ET-8500 / ET-8550
The Gold Standard

Epson EcoTank Photo ET-8500 / ET-8550

The only difference between the ET-8500 and ET-8550 is the supported paper size.

Image Quality
Text Quality
Cost Per Print
Cardstock Handling
Advantages
  • Refillable ink tanks
  • Pigment and Dye black inks
  • Excellent media handling, including thick cardstock
Disadvantages
  • Very high initial purchase price

Frequently Asked Questions

Why use ink tank printers for proxies?
Ink tank printers are ideal for printing proxies because they offer extremely low cost per print. When printing whole decks or cubes, you'll be producing a large number of cards, and ink tank systems let you print hundreds or thousands of pages before needing a refill—saving you money compared to traditional cartridge printers.
Why not recommend laser or office printers?
This guide focuses on printers that excel at producing high-quality, vibrant proxies for tabletop games. While office and laser printers are great for text and business documents, they often lack the color accuracy, photo quality, and media versatility needed for the best proxy cards.
Can I use regular paper for proxies?
You can, but for the best results, use heavyweight matte or glossy photo paper. This gives proxies a more authentic feel and better color reproduction, making them look and handle more like real cards.
How do I get the best print quality for proxies?
Use high-resolution images, set your printer to its highest quality/photo mode, and select the correct paper type in your printer settings. Clean your print heads regularly for consistent results.
Why not use a photo printer like Epson SureColor?
While professional photo printers like the Epson SureColor series offer exceptional image quality, they come with very high ink costs—especially when printing in volume, as you would for proxies. Additionally, these printers are often optimized for photo paper and may not handle heavier cardstock as reliably as the ink tank models recommended here.
What's the difference between pigment and dye black inks?
Pigment-based black inks are great for matte paper and any paper that specifically supports pigment inks. However, when printing on glossy paper (or when you set your media type to glossy in printer settings), printers with pigment black will combine colors to create black instead of using the dedicated black ink. This results in less crisp, less deep blacks compared to dye-based black inks, which work well on both matte and glossy surfaces.